My favourites from 2019, in no particular order.
11 – Bowmore Hand-filled 54.0%
42 – Ichiro’s Malt Single Cask 2019 rum Cask #5821 9 years old
84 – Ledaig 8 Years by Signatory for TWE’s 20th Anniversary cask 700389
90 – Bowmore 1995 by Wemyss “Nostalgic 70’s Flavour”
100 – Balmenach 2001 by MASAM cask 06/06081
124 – Craigellachie 12 for Quaich Bar Cask #39215 PX
Nose that is strongly honeyed, with cold butter and minerality. Some liquorice and caramel, slight ozone and green hills. Palate has honey continuing, deep woody notes and controlled sulfur there is a lovely puff of marshmallow. That honey note is even in the finish and there is some real earthy soil.
****
125 – Springbank 12, 1996 NC2 by Duncan Taylor 46%
Nose of honey, hay and (unpleasantly) plasticine but the apricots and tropical fruits are positive. The palate is gentle and tropical with dried salted mango and a hint of peanut brittle. Simple finish of grape vines. Hmmm… disappointing.
**
126 – Ichiro’s Malt & Grain 2019 bourbon barrel for The Whisky Plus cask 7172 59%
Delicious grilled bananas with brown sugar on the nose followed by raspberry lollies, dried pineapple, vanilla and crushed ants. Palate is very bourbon like toasted pound cake with vanilla cream, butter, some stone fruit, waffle cones. Lovely long but simple finish of tropical fruits and rancio.
****
127 – Longrow 1993 10 year old
Nose of lemon barley! Some old bottle effect is there but it blows away with time to revea caramel, hay, salt and pepper. The palate has some Campbeltown funk, bruised apples in light caramel sauce with toasted sesame seeds. The finish has more bruised apple then apricot seeds and green grass.
****
Diageo’s Flora and Fauna series was front and centre for The Elysian’s 3rd birthday! Strap in for 15 drams.
109 – Strathmill 12yo
Great nose of lemon curd slathered on shortbread, dried ginger, green cardamom, egg white. But it comes apart on the boring palate of unripe pear and olive oil. This finish is overly salty with hints of underripe stonefruit and some cream.
**
110 – Linkwood 12yo
Nose has some lovely green apple sorbet notes with creme fraiche, dry baking spices, dried apricots and vanilla bean. Transforms on the palate to ice cream and sun ripened slightly green apricots. The whole vanilla/cream thing continues to be melted ice cream on the finish.
***
111 – Glendullan 12yo
Simple but pleasant nose of caramel and was spicy like an uncooked apple crumble. Palate was quite neutral nothing really stood out but had a great mouthfeel. It was heavy and chewy. How is this a 4 star rating? The finish, long and deep! It was amazingly creamy and full of bitter almonds like marzipan and frangipane tart. For a simple whisky the finish lifts this to an excellent whisky.
****
112 – Dailuaine 16yo (Discontinued)
Nose was very elegant. It had lovely dried rose petals, dried stone fruit all sprinkled with brown sugar and a healthy dose of cream. Tastes of hay and coffee grounds leading into hand cream and dark chocolate. Indulgent finish of a chocolate and caramel cake.
****
113 – Rosebank 12yo (Closed Distillery)
Fruit medley nose with dried apples, tinned pineapple, young ginger. Some interesting whiffs of vanilla pod and curiously dry bones. The palate is grassy, with more orchard and stone fruits, some lovely hints of marshmallow and leather. Simple finish that grassy and salt.
***
114 – Blair Athol 12yo
Sherry influenced nose – wood varnish, caramel, snickers bars and a touch of rubber. The palate has sweet tea tannins and touches of flat coke. There is some nice fruit of dried peaches and muscat grapes. Beautiful white peach and salted butter finish.
****
115 – Auchroisk 10yo
Confusing nose of marischino cherries and marzipan, tomato paste, pears. The pear notes continue with pear tea cake with cream on the palate. Pears return on the finish with a salty and saline, pear juice lick.
***
116 – Inchgower 14yo
Promising nose of hand cream, baking spice and dry cocoa. Some grassy notes and a touch of apricot leather. The palate reminds of stewed apricots with cloves and pepper, unfortunately a saltiness interferes. Cream, baking spice and flat lemonade to finish.
***
117 – Mannochmore 12yo
Nose of glue, lemon, shortbread and slightly salty peanut shells. An initial floral palate moves to sweet tea and slight snickers bar. The finish continues slightly nutty and a lovely floral note.
***
118 – Glen Spey 12yo
The nose was really really interesting with a mixture of minerality and Portuguese tarts. The Portuguese tarts were just there when tasting as it was overwhelmed by dry spice and not much else. The finish was overly grassy.
**
119 – Mortlach 16yo (Discontinued)
Wonderfully complex nose of lemon zest, dried rose petals, apricots, caramel, butter, chocolate and dusty shelves, hay and sweet tea… so many layers. Palate with great stone fruit of dried apricots and green peaches and a surprising note of liquorice and fennel. Just falls a bit short on the finish slight stone fruit notes and salty.
****
120 – Pittyvaich 12yo (Closed Distillery)
Nose of dried orange zest, furniture varnish, woody, salted lemon zest, brown sugar and melted butter. Sherry sherry sherry! Palate of coffee, toffee, with a surprising mulch and woody note, dried cherries, wine grapes. Lovely finish of spent coffee filters and melted butter.
****
121 – Bladnoch 10yo (Discontinued)
Woooo!!! Bourbon nose! Mango, green apricots and pineapple, grassy, hand cream. Palate of salty roasted peanuts and dried mango. On the finish it moves really nicely into hay and cream. A solid dram.
***
122 – Glenlossie 10yo
Interesting nose of peanuts, fresh strawberries and green coconut. A cooling mouthfeel makes way for grassy, hay, bounty bar, tea tannin palate. Interesting and complex finish of mango seeds, salt and slight butter and some bitter notes of dark chocolate, grape seed.
***
123 – Benrinnes 15yo
Nose of manuka honey and aspirin and it becomes quite flinty and mineral with touches of caramel. Wonderfully umami palate with flavours of soy sauce and nori butter, Parmesan rind. Finish of coffee grains and more butter!
***
108 – Ben Nevis 1996 by Elixir Distillers, sherry butt cask #1528
Great nose of honey and caramel, marshmallows and strong minerality. Falling rose petals in a rose garden.
Honey, green grass and coal. Reminds me of the tar shampoo I used as a kid. The grassy note is a little too strong for me and takes away from the honey. A bit of burnt camp sausage floats in.
Straight forward finish is flinty, with green grass again and a hint of cream.
***
102 – Blackadder Raw Cask Aultmore 2006 11yo, 57.6% Cask #307142
Nose starts tropical with strong dried pineapple and mango skin, sweet honey, raw pastry, salted lemons
Palate of milky sweet tea. It’s malty with tropical and stone fruit. A hint of flinty minerality.
Finish is a simple salty butter.
****
103 – Firkin Whisky Co Firkin 49 Tullibardine 2011 8yo Oloroso Amontillado Casks, 48.9%
The nose was nutty, clear stone fruit, lemon sip, milk chocolate.
Palate had a lovely iced coffee note. Followed by heather, flinty, Brazil nuts and a touch a salty citrus.
Finish of cold salted butter, kopiko (coffee) lollies.
***
104 – Firkin Whisky Co Firkin Ten Royal Brackla 2008 10yo Madeira Cask, 48.9%
Nose: Rose heads, peach ice tea, my mum’s Madeira cake (yes I’m serious)
Palate: great mouthfeel, light tropical, nutty,
Finish: long finish, liquorice, flourless orange cake
****
105 – Blackadder Raw Cask The Old Man Of Hoy 2005 12yo 2018 Batch 1 Single Orcadian Malt, 60.7%
Nose was rubbery and chocolate which makes me think HP. Has very good seaweed and maritime elements.
On the palate it is heavy, honey and charcoal dominant. Pleasant sweet rubbery notes.
The finish becomes flinty and minerally and heavy with wet stones.
****
106 – Firkin Whisky Co Firkin Islay Caol Ila 2012 7yo Marsala Cask, 48.9%
Nose super maritime, gluey, dark chocolate, sweet lemons, corn chips
Palate has a gorgeous mouth feel, really flinty, stones and campfire
Finish of band-aids, dusty, toasted almonds and campfire
****
107 – Blackadder Raw Cask Smoking Islay Blended Malt 2019, 60.2%
Nose of glue and honey, chlorine,
Palate smokey, autumn leaves, pool water
Finish glue, salt and sea water, burnt leaves
**
100 – Balmenach 2001 by MASAM cask 06/06081
Nose is like fino sherry. The salt, the spray, the nuttiness. Some oyster shell and leather. With time the caramel, notes ring.
Palate is creamy, burnt wood giving way to stone fruit and camp fire rocks with a driving minerality.
Finish is clear and fun boiled sweets, fruit tingles and sherry saltiness
*****
101 – Bunnahabhain 40 years by MASAM cask 7229
Nose full of fruit and apricots, cream and light caramel, pencil shavings. Would not pick it as a Bunna.
Pencil shavings, candle wax, intense jasmine tea, stewed fruit, and soy sauce on the palate.
Finish of waxed fruit, apples and stewed apricots with cream
****
97 – Bruichladdich 2004 13yo by Silent Third Kyoto Cask 1543
Heavy maple and crispy bacon smoke on the nose, with heather and rich nori butter
Palate of wood smoke with a great heavy coating mouthfeel. The caramel and peat very fell integrated into orange zest scented Xmas pud.
The orange zest continues on the finish and turns dusty into date and date syrup.
****
98 – Tweeddale “Grain if Truth” 46%
Nose: Honey leads to jersey caramel and a slight earthy new make smell.
Palate: nicely sweet and then some nice chocolate milk notes but that’s about it. It’s simple.
Finish: Stays chocolate milk and hot and a little cream. Pretty flat on the finish though.
*
99 – Littlemill 1988 bottled in 2015 by Pearls of Scotland Cask #135
Nose is intensely over sherried wood, leather, maple syrup and hairspray.
.
Initially sweet and spicy, it is rancio in the extreme. Some great plump raisins and cooked pastry but those old wood notes are a frontal assault. There is really clear fresh and dried figs.
.
Finish is salty and woody, unsurprisingly.
.
Love this dram for it’s uniqueness… but objectively it is only good as those woody rancio notes are ridiculous.
***
